The administration of a trust in South Africa is often incorrectly viewed as little more than an administrative or accounting exercise. In practice, however, trust administration is an ongoing legal and fiduciary governance function governed by the common law, the Trust Property Control Act 57 of 1988 (“TPCA”), the provisions of the trust deed, and an increasingly demanding regulatory and tax environment.
A trust is not a static structure that can simply be created and left unattended. From inception to termination, it requires continuous oversight, active trustee participation, careful record-keeping, and ongoing compliance with fiduciary, statutory, and tax obligations. The effectiveness of a trust structure ultimately depends less on the wording of the trust deed itself, and more on how the trust is administered in practice over time.
Trust Administration at a Glance
| Question | Short answer |
| Can a trust be “dormant”? | No. Unlike companies, trusts cannot be placed into dormancy; trustee obligations continue even without economic activity |
| What are the three pillars? | (i) Legal establishment and structural integrity; (ii) continuous fiduciary and statutory compliance; (iii) tax compliance and reporting |
| When can trustees validly bind the trust? | Only once the Master has issued Letters of Authority (section 6(1) TPCA) |
| What new transparency duty applies? | Since 1 April 2023, trustees must record and lodge a beneficial ownership register with the Master (section 11A TPCA) |
| Must a trust with no income file tax returns? | Yes. The annual ITR12T return remains mandatory even with little or no activity |
| What is the biggest risk? | Governance failure, which can lead to the trust being treated as the alter ego of the founder or controlling trustees |
The Misconception of “Dormant” Trusts
The concept of a “dormant” trust is a misconception in practice. Unlike companies, trusts cannot be placed into a state of dormancy. The absence of economic activity does not suspend the trust’s legal existence or the obligations imposed on trustees.
Even where a trust holds no income-producing assets, or merely retains lifestyle assets such as immovable property or vehicles used by beneficiaries, the governance burden remains intact. Trustees are still required to:
- Ensure proper decision-making processes.
- Maintain records.
- Comply with statutory obligations.
Inactivity does not equate to reduced responsibility; it often increases risk due to neglect.
The Three Pillars of Trust Administration
From a practical governance perspective, effective trust administration rests on three interdependent pillars:
- Legal establishment and structural integrity.
- Continuous fiduciary and statutory compliance.
- Tax compliance and reporting obligations.
Weakness in any one of these areas can compromise the integrity of the trust as a whole.
Pillar One: Legal Establishment and Structural Integrity
The long-term stability of a trust begins with its legal establishment. Defects introduced at inception seldom remain isolated to the formation stage; rather, they tend to follow the trust throughout its lifecycle and often emerge only once the trust is scrutinised during litigation, commercial transactions, or disputes between beneficiaries.
A Carefully Drafted Trust Deed
A properly constituted trust requires a carefully drafted trust deed that clearly identifies:
- The trust object.
- The beneficiaries.
- The nature of the rights created.
The distinction between discretionary and vested rights is particularly significant. Ambiguous drafting or incorrect classification frequently creates interpretative uncertainty, governance complications, and unintended legal or tax consequences.
Letters of Authority from the Master of the High Court
Registration with the Master of the High Court is equally critical. Trustees derive their authority not merely from appointment, but from the issuance of Letters of Authority under section 6(1) of the TPCA. Until such authority has been issued, trustees are generally incapable of validly binding the trust.
Transactions concluded prematurely may therefore be void and incapable of subsequent ratification, as held in Simplex (Pty) Ltd v Van der Merwe and Others NNO 1996 (1) SA 111 (W). Although that approach was initially contested, notably in Kropman and Others NNO v Nysschen 1999 (2) SA 567 (T), the Supreme Court of Appeal has since confirmed that acts performed without the Master’s authorisation are a nullity: Lupacchini NO and Another v Minister of Safety and Security 2010 (6) SA 457 (SCA).
Hidden Weaknesses and Alter Ego Trusts
These structural weaknesses often remain hidden for years before surfacing at precisely the wrong moment. Counterparties, creditors, beneficiaries, or courts may challenge:
- Whether trustees were properly authorised.
- Whether resolutions were validly adopted.
- Whether the trust itself operated independently.
In more serious cases, governance failures may contribute to findings that the trust lacked genuine independence altogether, undermining both its legal standing and its asset protection objective, as the authorities on alter ego trusts, including Badenhorst v Badenhorst 2006 (2) SA 255 (SCA), illustrate.
The threshold remains a demanding one: in Van Zyl and Another NNO v Kaye NO and Others 2014 (4) SA 452 (WCC) the court distinguished a sham trust from the trust form, and held that even a trustee who administers a trust without proper regard to his fiduciary duties does not thereby render the trust a sham.
Pillar Two: Continuous Fiduciary and Statutory Compliance
The true substance of a trust lies in the conduct of its trustees. Trustees occupy fiduciary positions and are required to exercise their powers jointly, in good faith, and with the degree of care, diligence, and skill expected of persons entrusted with the management of another’s property. These obligations are not occasional duties triggered only during transactions; they are continuous responsibilities attaching to the office of trustee itself.
Acting Within the Trust Deed and Recording Resolutions
Central to proper administration is the requirement that trustees act strictly within the powers conferred upon them by the trust deed. Decisions must be properly considered, formally adopted, and accurately recorded through trustee resolutions.
Informal arrangements, verbal understandings, or unilateral conduct by individual trustees frequently create serious legal difficulties, particularly where transactions are later challenged. In many cases, the absence of proper resolutions becomes the very basis upon which the validity of trustee conduct is attacked.
Conflicts of Interest
Conflicts of interest present an additional and recurring area of risk. Trustees are required to maintain independence and may not place themselves in positions where personal interests conflict with their fiduciary obligations. Where trustees derive unauthorised personal benefit from trust property, or treat trust assets as extensions of their own estates, courts have shown a clear willingness to intervene.
Beneficial Ownership Register and Record Retention (TPCA Sections 11A, 16 and 17)
Since 1 April 2023, trustees have also carried express transparency obligations. Section 11A of the TPCA, inserted by the General Laws (Anti-Money Laundering and Combating Terrorism Financing) Amendment Act 22 of 2022, requires trustees to:
- Establish and record the beneficial ownership of the trust.
- Keep that record up to date.
- Lodge a register of the prescribed beneficial ownership information with the Master of the High Court.
- Record the prescribed details of any accountable institution used to invest or manage trust property.
These obligations apply irrespective of the level of activity within the trust, and non-compliance attracts statutory penalties in addition to the governance exposure described above.
Separately:
- Section 17 of the TPCA requires trustees to retain trust documents for five years after termination of the trust.
- Section 16 entitles the Master to call for accounts and vouchers at any time.
Pillar Three: Tax Compliance and Reporting Obligations for Trusts
Trusts occupy a unique and heavily scrutinised position within South African tax law. As separate taxpayers, they are subject to extensive reporting and compliance obligations which continue irrespective of whether the trust is actively trading or generating income.
ITR12T and IT3(t) Returns
- The submission of annual ITR12T returns remains mandatory, even where the trust has experienced little or no economic activity during the relevant tax period. Trustees bear the responsibility of ensuring that all returns are accurate, complete, and properly supported by underlying documentation.
- In addition, most trusts are now required to submit IT3(t) third-party returns disclosing amounts vested in beneficiaries, including net income, capital gains, and repayments of contributions, in terms of section 26 of the Tax Administration Act 28 of 2011 read with General Notice 3631 of 30 June 2023.
Record-Keeping Under the Tax Administration Act
Beyond the submission of returns, trustees are also subject to extensive record-keeping obligations under the Tax Administration Act 28 of 2011. Section 29, read with sections 30 to 32, requires taxpayers to keep records, books of account, and documents sufficient to satisfy that their tax obligations have been properly discharged, while section 25 regulates the submission of returns. Failures in this regard frequently expose trusts to penalties, interest, verification procedures, and increased audit scrutiny.
Distributions, Beneficiary Accounts and Loan Accounts
Particular attention is often directed toward trust distributions, beneficiary accounts, and loan arrangements. Where these transactions are poorly documented, inconsistently recorded, or unsupported by valid resolutions, SARS may challenge their legal substance and tax treatment. In practice, undocumented loan accounts and irregular distributions often become the source of significant adverse tax consequences, including the characterisation of transactions and the imposition of additional assessments.
The Primary Risk of Loss: Governance and Administration Failures
The primary risks associated with trusts seldom arise from market exposure alone, but rather from failures in governance and administration. South African courts have repeatedly shown a willingness to disregard the trust form where trustees fail to maintain a clear separation between their personal affairs and those of the trust.
What begins as minor non-compliance can quickly escalate into significant legal and financial exposure:
- Invalid transactions. Transactions may later be challenged as invalid due to defective resolutions or the absence of proper trustee authority.
- Tax consequences. These may arise where transactions are incorrectly structured, recorded, or characterised.
- Loss of asset protection. Most critically, the asset protection ordinarily associated with a trust can be undermined entirely if the trust is found to operate merely as an alter ego of the founder or controlling trustees.
Beneficiary Disputes and Personal Liability of Trustees
Beneficiary disputes further compound these risks. Poor record-keeping, inconsistent trustee conduct, and undocumented decision-making frequently leave trustees unable to substantiate the basis upon which decisions were taken. When disputes arise, trustees are often exposed not only to costly litigation, but also to removal from office and, in certain circumstances, personal financial liability.
Proper trust administration is therefore not a procedural formality, but an essential safeguard preserving the validity, independence, and protective purpose of the trust structure itself.
A Trustee’s Compliance Checklist
Use this as a starting point for your next trustee meeting:
- Do all trustees hold current Letters of Authority from the Master?
- Is the trust deed clear on the trust object, beneficiaries and whether rights are discretionary or vested?
- Is every significant decision recorded in a formal trustee resolution?
- Do trustees act jointly and strictly within the powers in the deed?
- Are conflicts of interest declared and managed?
- Is the beneficial ownership register current and lodged with the Master?
- Are the prescribed details of any accountable institution used to invest or manage trust property recorded?
- Are trust documents kept, with a plan to retain them for five years after termination?
- Can the trust produce accounts and vouchers if the Master asks?
- Is the annual ITR12T filed, even in a quiet year?
- Are IT3(t) returns filed where required?
- Are distributions, beneficiary accounts and loan accounts documented and supported by resolutions?
- Is the trust’s banking and property kept separate from trustees’ personal affairs?
Conclusion: Good Governance Preserves the Trust’s Legitimacy and Asset Protection
Trusts remain powerful legal and estate planning instruments when properly administered. Their effectiveness, however, depends not only on their creation, but on the quality and consistency of their ongoing governance.
In practice, most trust-related losses do not arise from external economic forces, but from internal administrative failures, inadequate oversight, and a gradual breakdown of fiduciary discipline. Proper trust administration is therefore not simply a compliance exercise; it is the mechanism through which the trust’s legitimacy, asset protection objectives, and long-term legal integrity are preserved.
For help with trust administration, trustee duties, or a review of your trust’s compliance, contact an expert at SchoemanLaw Inc in Cape Town or Paarl. If you are still considering whether to set one up, see our guide to family trusts in South Africa.


