Your Company Is Facing an Urgent Court Application. What Should You Do in the First 48 Hours

Just been served? Send the full papers to your attorneys immediately, note the hearing date and time, and instruct your staff not to delete anything. Contact SchoemanLaw Inc in Cape Town or Paarl as soon as possible.

Few documents cause as much alarm in a boardroom as an urgent court application served on a company with a hearing date only days, or even hours, away.

This article sets out a practical approach for the first 48 hours.

The First 48 Hours at a Glance

Timing Priority
Hour 0 to 24 Read the papers and diarise deadlines; instruct attorneys; escalate and appoint a decision-maker; preserve evidence; check insurance and contractual notices; control communications
Hour 24 to 48 Decide strategy; prepare the answering affidavit (urgency first, then merits); decide who will depose to it and confirm authority
Throughout Test whether the matter is truly urgent; avoid the common mistakes listed below

Why Urgent Applications in the High Court Are Different

In urgent applications in the High Court, the court may dispense with the usual forms and service periods and hear the matter in the manner it considers fit. The rule is therefore an exception to the ordinary timetable, not a faster version of it. In its supporting affidavit, the applicant must explicitly set out the circumstances said to make the matter urgent and the reasons why substantial redress could not be obtained at a hearing in due course.

Urgency Is Itself a Ground of Defence

This matters to a respondent, because urgency is itself a ground of defence. Courts assess urgency objectively and are reluctant to assist an applicant whose urgency is self-created, for example where the applicant knew of the problem for weeks or months and only then asked the court to shorten the respondent’s time to respond.

A matter that is not truly urgent is ordinarily struck from the roll. Each High Court division also has its own practice directives governing urgent matters, so the local requirements must be checked immediately.

The First 24 Hours: Understand, Secure and Escalate

  1. Read the papers and diarise every deadline. Establish the court, the date and time of the hearing, the relief sought, and any dates by which a notice of opposition or answering affidavit is required. The notice of motion often sets these out. Do not assume that a short deadline is unalterable, but do not assume it is flexible either.
  2. Instruct attorneys immediately. An urgent application cannot be managed by email chains between executives. Send the full papers to your attorneys without delay, together with the contact details of the people who can give instructions and sign affidavits. Early instruction allows counsel to be briefed while there is still time to prepare properly.
  3. Escalate internally and establish who is in charge. Inform the directors or executive team, and nominate one decision-maker and one point of contact for the legal team. Confirm who is authorised to depose to affidavits and to settle the matter on the company’s behalf, and record the necessary resolutions.
  4. Preserve evidence. Issue an instruction that documents, emails, messages, contracts, and system logs relevant to the dispute must not be deleted, altered, or discarded, including under any routine deletion schedule. Destroying evidence after a dispute has arisen can seriously damage the company’s case and its credibility.
  5. Check insurance and contractual notice obligations. Some policies and agreements require prompt notification of claims or proceedings. A late notice may jeopardise cover, so these should be reviewed on day one.
  6. Be careful with communications. Staff should not discuss the matter with the applicant, the media, or on social media. Statements made informally may later be used as evidence. Communications with the legal team should be directed to your attorneys so that privilege is preserved.

The Second 24 Hours: Decide the Response and Prepare the Papers

Once the facts are gathered, the company and its legal team need to decide on a strategy. The main options include:

  • Opposing the application on the merits and/or on urgency, and asking that the matter be struck from the roll with costs.
  • Asking the applicant to agree to a reasonable timetable for the exchange of papers, or to remove the matter from the urgent roll.
  • Offering a limited, interim undertaking, such as agreeing to preserve the status quo pending a proper hearing, which may remove the need for urgent relief.
  • Settling or complying, where the claim is well-founded and continued opposition would only increase costs and risk.
  • A combination of these, such as opposing urgency while offering a narrowly tailored undertaking.

The Answering Affidavit Is the Centrepiece

Whichever route is chosen, the answering affidavit is the centrepiece of the response. It should:

  • Deal with urgency first and then the merits.
  • Be accurate and complete.
  • Be supported by documents.

Courts will expect the company to answer the allegations made against it, and a version of events that is later shown to be incomplete can cost the company dearly. Where full answering papers cannot be finalised in the time available, the attorneys may be able to deliver a shorter affidavit dealing with the most important points and reserve the right to supplement it.

Who Should Sign the Affidavit?

The company should also decide who will depose to the affidavit. The deponent should have personal knowledge of the facts, or be able to rely on supporting affidavits from those who do, and must be properly authorised.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Served With an Urgent Application

  • Ignoring the papers or assuming the matter will go away.
  • Waiting until the day before the hearing to brief attorneys.
  • Failing to attend court or to file a notice of opposition, which may result in an order being granted by default.
  • Making assertions in affidavits that the company cannot support with documents.
  • Deleting or altering records after the dispute has arisen.
  • Treating the application only as a legal problem, and neglecting to manage the operational, reputational and employee consequences.

An Urgent Application Response Checklist

  • Hearing court, date and time recorded
  • Relief sought understood
  • Deadlines for notice of opposition and answering affidavit diarised
  • Full papers sent to attorneys
  • Decision-maker and legal point of contact appointed
  • Authority to depose and to settle confirmed, resolutions recorded
  • Document-preservation instruction issued, routine deletion suspended
  • Insurance and contractual notice obligations reviewed
  • Communications protocol issued to staff
  • Practice directives for the relevant High Court division checked
  • Urgency challenge assessed (is the urgency self-created?)
  • Strategy chosen (oppose, timetable, undertaking, settle or combination)
  • Answering affidavit drafted, urgency first, supported by documents
  • Operational, reputational and employee impacts managed

Conclusion: A Structured Response Makes a Considerable Difference

An urgent application leaves little time for reflection, but a structured response makes a considerable difference. In the first 48 hours, a company should understand the papers, instruct attorneys, preserve evidence, decide on strategy, and prepare an accurate answering affidavit, while testing whether the matter is truly urgent.

This article is general information and not legal advice, and each matter depends on its own facts and the practice directives of the relevant court.

For urgent litigation support, contact an expert at SchoemanLaw Inc in Cape Town or Paarl.

related news & insights.