Handwritten-Wills-Can-a-Document-That-Does-Not-Comply-With-the-Formalities-Still-Be-Valid

A will is one of the most important documents a person can prepare, as it determines how their estate should be dealt with after their death. However, circumstances do not always allow a person to have a professionally drafted will properly executed. In some instances, a person may prepare a handwritten document setting out their wishes, without complying with all the formalities prescribed by law.

Does this mean that the document is automatically invalid?

The answer is not necessarily. The Wills Act 7 of 1953 (“the Wills Act”) makes provision for a court to recognise a document as a valid will, despite non-compliance with certain execution formalities, provided that the requirements of the Act are satisfied.

A recent judgment of the Gauteng Local Division of the High Court, S.F.S v J.L.R and Others [2026] ZAGPJHC 1242, provides an interesting illustration of how the courts approach these applications, particularly when determining whether a deceased person genuinely intended a handwritten document to operate as their will.

Handwritten Wills at a Glance

Question Short answer
Is a handwritten will valid? It can be, provided it complies with the applicable formalities. The Wills Act does not require a will to be typed or prepared by an attorney
What if it was not properly witnessed? A court may direct the Master to accept it as a will under section 2(3), if satisfied the deceased drafted or executed it and intended it to be their will
Is section 2(3) a general exemption? No. It is not a way around the formalities. Instructions about how someone would like their estate distributed are not enough on their own
When must the intention have existed? At the time the document was drafted or executed, not only after death
Who must prove lack of mental capacity? The person alleging it (section 4)
What is the safest approach? A properly drafted and executed will, which avoids uncertainty, disputes and extra costs for your family

The Formal Requirements of a Valid Will in South Africa

Section 2(1)(a) of the Wills Act prescribes the formalities that must ordinarily be complied with when executing a will. Among other requirements:

  • A will must be signed at the end by the testator, or by another person in the testator’s presence and at their direction.
  • The signature must be made or acknowledged in the presence of at least two competent witnesses who are present at the same time.
  • The witnesses must then sign in the presence of the testator and each other.
  • Where a will consists of more than one page, each page other than the final page must also be signed by the testator or the person signing on their behalf.

These requirements are important because they help establish the authenticity of the document and protect against fraudulent or disputed wills.

Can a Will Be Handwritten?

Importantly, however, the Wills Act does not require a will to be typed or prepared by an attorney. A handwritten will may be valid, provided that it complies with the applicable formalities. The difficulty arises where a handwritten document records the deceased’s wishes but does not comply with the prescribed requirements.

Can a Court Recognise a Will That Does Not Comply With the Formalities?

Section 2(3) of the Wills Act makes provision for precisely these circumstances. It empowers a court to direct the Master of the High Court to accept a document as a will, notwithstanding its failure to comply with all the formalities prescribed by section 2(1), if the court is satisfied that:

  1. The document was drafted or executed by the deceased; and
  2. The deceased intended the document to be their will.

The purpose of this provision is to prevent a deceased person’s genuine testamentary wishes from being defeated merely because of non-compliance with technical formalities.

The Limits of Section 2(3)

However, section 2(3) is not a general exemption from the requirements of the Wills Act. A document cannot be recognised as a will simply because it contains instructions about how a person would like their estate to be distributed. The court must be satisfied that the deceased personally drafted or executed the document and intended it to operate as their will.

The intention must also have existed at the time the document was drafted or executed. It is therefore not sufficient that a document only came to be regarded as a will after the deceased’s death.

In determining this intention, the court considers the wording and contents of the document together with the surrounding circumstances.

Recent Case Law: S.F.S v J.L.R and Others [2026] ZAGPJHC 1242

The recent judgment in S.F.S v J.L.R and Others illustrates how these principles are applied in practice.

The Facts

  • The deceased had been hospitalised in December 2020 during the Covid-19 pandemic. At his request, his partner brought him a notebook and pen. On 25 December 2020, he returned the notebook containing a multi-page handwritten document which he had prepared and signed.
  • The document identified his family members, dealt with his assets and funeral policies, and contained detailed instructions regarding how his estate should be distributed. It was headed “Will”.
  • The deceased instructed his partner to have the document formalised by his legal insurer, LIPCO. However, the offices were closed for the festive season, and he was subsequently informed that formalisation would take approximately ten days.
  • Believing that he might not survive long enough for this to happen, the deceased made further efforts to have the document witnessed. Two individuals eventually signed it as witnesses, but they did so on separate occasions and not in each other’s presence or in the presence of the deceased. The requirements of section 2(1)(a) had therefore not been satisfied.
  • Following his death in January 2021, his partner approached the High Court for an order directing the Master to accept the handwritten document as his will in terms of section 2(3).

The respondents disputed the application, challenging both the authorship of the document and whether the deceased had genuinely intended it to be his will. They also raised concerns about his mental capacity at the time. The Court considered these issues separately.

The Importance of the Testator’s Intention

One of the central issues was whether the deceased intended the handwritten document to operate as his will, or whether it was merely a set of instructions for LIPCO to use when preparing a formal will.

The respondents argued that the document was preparatory in nature, particularly because the deceased had instructed LIPCO to “ratify” it and referred to his “signature approval”.

How the Court Distinguished Earlier Cases

In considering this argument, the Court distinguished the matter from previous decisions, including Ex parte Maurice 1995 (2) SA 713 (C), De Reszke v Maras and Others 2006 (2) SA 277 (SCA) and Williams and Others v Hendricks and Another 2021 (6) SA 551 (WCC). In those cases, the documents were found to be instructions or preliminary arrangements for the preparation of a will, rather than documents intended to operate as wills themselves.

The Court found that the circumstances in the present matter were materially different:

  • The document was expressly headed “Will”, identified the deceased’s beneficiaries and dealt with the distribution of his assets.
  • It concluded with his full name, identification number, signature and date, beneath the words “I the undersigned”.
  • The deceased referred to the document as “this will” when instructing LIPCO to ratify it. The Court considered that ratification meant confirming something that already existed, rather than creating something new.
  • The deceased’s subsequent conduct was also significant. When he became concerned that he might die before LIPCO could formalise the document, he took steps to have that very document witnessed. This reinforced the inference that he intended it to operate as his will in the meantime.

The Court accordingly found that the deceased intended the handwritten document to be his will when he signed it on 25 December 2020. The fact that he wanted it formally perfected did not detract from that intention.

Authorship and Mental Capacity

Who Wrote the Document?

The Court also had to determine whether the document had actually been drafted by the deceased. Although competing handwriting expert evidence had been presented, the Court considered the evidence as a whole, including:

  • The partner’s account of how the notebook was supplied and returned.
  • The deceased’s subsequent efforts to arrange for witnesses to sign the document.
  • The confirmatory affidavits of the two witnesses.

The respondents’ allegations of fraud were found to be speculative and unsupported by sufficient evidence. The Court was therefore satisfied that the deceased had authored the document.

Mental Capacity and the Burden of Proof

Regarding mental capacity, section 4 of the Wills Act places the burden of proving testamentary incapacity on the person alleging it.

The respondents had relied on the deceased’s apparent physical condition during his hospitalisation to suggest that he was not mentally capable of making a will. However, they had not placed medical evidence before the Court to substantiate this allegation.

The Court considered the contents of the document, which demonstrated that the deceased was able to identify his family members, recall his assets and provide detailed instructions regarding their distribution. His efforts to arrange for the document to be witnessed also supported his ability to understand what he was doing. The Court accordingly found no evidential basis to conclude that the deceased lacked the necessary mental capacity.

The Outcome

Ultimately, the Court directed the Master to accept the handwritten document as the deceased’s will in terms of section 2(3) of the Wills Act. The separate request to have the applicant declared the executrix was dismissed, as the appointment of executors falls within the Master’s powers.

What Courts Look at When Deciding Whether a Handwritten Document Is a Will

Drawing on the judgment, the following factors were relevant:

  • Heading and wording. Was the document headed “Will” and did it use language such as “I the undersigned”?
  • Did it identify beneficiaries and deal with the distribution of assets, rather than merely give instructions?
  • Signature and date. Was it signed and dated, with full name and identification number?
  • How the deceased described it. Did they refer to it as “this will”?
  • Subsequent conduct. Did they take steps to have that very document witnessed or formalised?
  • Does the evidence as a whole, including witnesses and any handwriting experts, show the deceased wrote or executed it?
  • Is there medical or other evidence of incapacity? The person alleging incapacity bears the burden.

Conclusion: The Safest Approach Is a Properly Drafted and Executed Will

The judgment in S.F.S v J.L.R and Others reinforces the importance of distinguishing between a document that merely records a person’s wishes and one that was genuinely intended to operate as their will.

While the Wills Act provides a mechanism through which a court may recognise a document despite non-compliance with the prescribed formalities, this does not mean that those formalities can simply be disregarded. The deceased must have personally drafted or executed the document and must have intended it to be their will at the relevant time.

The judgment also demonstrates that a person’s intention is not necessarily determined by the wording of a document in isolation. Its contents, the circumstances in which it was prepared, and the deceased’s subsequent conduct may all be relevant in establishing what the deceased intended.

Ultimately, the safest approach remains to have a properly drafted and executed will in place. Relying on a handwritten document and a subsequent court application introduces uncertainty, potential disputes, and additional costs for those left behind.

For assistance with drafting or reviewing a will, or advice regarding the administration of a deceased estate, contact SchoemanLaw Inc in Cape Town or Paarl.

related news & insights.