Missed a deadline? Condonation is not automatic, and every day of delay needs an explanation. Speak to an attorney at SchoemanLaw Inc in Cape Town or Paarl as soon as possible.
The Labour Court Rules and the CCMA Rules permit the condonation of procedural non-compliance where good cause is shown. Condonation, however, is not granted as a matter of right. An applicant seeking to excuse a late referral, review, or other procedural step bears the burden of demonstrating why the indulgence should be granted.
The principle that “condonation is not there for the mere asking” remains firmly established in labour litigation. The courts have consistently emphasised that procedural timeframes serve to promote certainty, finality, and the expeditious resolution of disputes. A failure to comply with these timeframes requires a proper explanation and cannot simply be overlooked because a party wishes to pursue the underlying dispute.
In determining whether condonation should be granted, the court or tribunal will ordinarily consider:
- The extent of the delay.
- The explanation for it.
- The prospects of success.
- Prejudice to the parties.
- Any other relevant circumstances.
These factors are interrelated and must be considered collectively, having regard to the interests of justice.
Condonation at a Glance
| Question | Short answer |
| Is condonation automatic? | No. It is not granted as a matter of right, and the applicant bears the burden |
| What is the test? | Good cause, assessed by weighing all the factors together in the interests of justice |
| What must the explanation cover? | The entire period of delay, not just the initial failure |
| Can I blame my attorney or union? | Reliance on representatives does not automatically excuse a default, particularly if you do not explain your own conduct |
| Do prospects of success matter? | Yes. You must show the underlying claim is reasonably capable of succeeding, not just assert that the dismissal was unfair |
| Can a weak explanation still succeed? | Sometimes, in the case of a short delay, reasonable prospects, limited prejudice and the interests of justice (see Bosch) |
The Factors Determining Whether Condonation Should Be Granted
A Satisfactory Explanation for the Entire Delay
The applicant must provide a satisfactory explanation for the entire period of delay, not merely the initial failure to comply with the prescribed timeframe. The explanation should identify:
- What caused the delay.
- When the applicant became aware of the default.
- What steps were taken thereafter to remedy it.
Prospects of Success
The prospects of success in the underlying dispute are equally relevant. An applicant must demonstrate that the underlying claim is reasonably capable of succeeding and cannot rely merely on a general assertion that the dismissal was unfair or that the employer acted unlawfully.
Prejudice
Prejudice must also be considered, including the potential impact of allowing a dispute to proceed after a substantial delay and the prejudice that may arise if condonation is refused.
No single factor is decisive, although an inadequate explanation for the delay may, in appropriate circumstances, be fatal to the application.
An Inadequate Explanation for Delay: Aspen Holdings v Phelane
In Aspen Holdings Pty Ltd and Another v Phelane and Another (JA 71/23) [2025] ZALAC 4, the Labour Appeal Court considered an application for condonation involving a 41-day delay in filing a statement of case. The employee attributed the delay to incorrect legal advice regarding the applicable timeframe.
The Court, however, identified a further period of delay after the employee became aware of the procedural default, which had also not been adequately explained. It held that the failure to account for the entire period of delay was fatal to the application.
What Aspen Holdings Teaches
The judgment reinforces that applicants must explain not only how the initial deadline was missed, but also why they failed to act promptly once the non-compliance became apparent. Reliance on legal representatives does not automatically excuse procedural default, particularly where the applicant fails to adequately explain their own conduct.
Substantial Delay and No Satisfactory Explanation: Lunguza v CCMA
In Lunguza and Others v CCMA and Others (J215/21) [2025] ZALCJHB 454, the Labour Court considered condonation applications involving significantly late referrals of unfair dismissal disputes. The delays varied between the applicants, with some referrals being several months late and others substantially longer.
The applicants’ explanations were insufficiently substantiated, while their prospects of success were also undermined by deficiencies in the evidence supporting their claims.
The Court reiterated that condonation requires a proper explanation for the delay and a consideration of the prospects of success, prejudice, and the interests of justice. The applicants’ failure to adequately explain the delays and establish sufficient prospects of success resulted in the dismissal of the application.
What Lunguza Teaches
The judgment demonstrates that an employee’s desire to pursue an unfair dismissal claim does not, in itself, justify condonation where procedural non-compliance remains inadequately explained.
A Short Delay and Reasonable Prospects of Success: Bosch v Seynhaeve
A different outcome was reached in Bosch v Seynhaeve NO and Others (159/2023) [2024] ZALCCT 25, where the Labour Court considered an application arising from an eight-day delay in referring an unfair dismissal dispute to the SALGBC.
Although the explanation for the delay was weak, the Court found that the arbitrator had failed properly to consider:
- The employee’s prospects of success.
- The limited prejudice to the employer.
- The interests of fairness.
Considering the relevant factors collectively, the Court concluded that condonation ought to have been granted. The arbitrator’s ruling was set aside and condonation granted.
What Bosch Teaches
Bosch illustrates that an unsatisfactory explanation does not invariably result in the refusal of condonation. A short delay, reasonable prospects of success, limited prejudice, and the broader interests of justice may collectively justify granting the indulgence.
Comparing the Three Cases
| Case | Delay | Explanation | Prospects | Outcome |
| Aspen Holdings v Phelane (LAC) | 41 days (statement of case) | Incorrect legal advice; further period unexplained | Not the deciding factor | Condonation refused: failure to account for the entire delay was fatal |
| Lunguza v CCMA (Labour Court) | Several months or longer (unfair dismissal referrals) | Insufficiently substantiated | Undermined by deficient evidence | Application dismissed |
| Bosch v Seynhaeve (Labour Court) | 8 days (referral to SALGBC) | Weak | Reasonable | Arbitrator’s ruling set aside; condonation granted |
Practical Considerations in Preparing Condonation Applications
These judgments illustrate that condonation applications require more than a brief explanation for late filing. Applicants should:
- Provide a detailed chronology accounting for the entire period of delay.
- Explain when the default was discovered and what steps were taken thereafter.
- Substantiate reliance on attorneys, union representatives, or other advisers.
- Demonstrate reasonable prospects of success in the underlying dispute.
- Address prejudice to both parties and the interests of justice.
A failure to explain material periods of delay may result in the application being dismissed without the underlying dispute ever being determined on its merits.
A Condonation Application Checklist
- A dated chronology covering every day from the missed deadline to the date of the application
- The date and manner in which you discovered the default
- What you did immediately afterwards, and when
- Documents supporting your explanation (emails, messages, correspondence with advisers)
- If relying on an attorney, union official or other adviser: their account and your own steps
- A clear statement of why the underlying claim is reasonably capable of succeeding, with supporting evidence
- The prejudice to each party if condonation is granted or refused
- A submission on why the interests of justice favour granting condonation
Conclusion: Condonation Is an Indulgence, Not an Entitlement
Condonation serves an important purpose in labour litigation by allowing procedural non-compliance to be excused where the interests of justice warrant it. It does not, however, afford parties an unrestricted opportunity to disregard prescribed timeframes.
The decisions in Aspen Holdings, Lunguza, and Bosch demonstrate that condonation is determined by weighing the relevant circumstances as a whole. A poor explanation, excessive delay, or weak prospects of success may undermine an application, while a short delay, plausible claim, and limited prejudice may favour granting the indulgence.
The lesson is clear: every period of delay must be accounted for, the merits must be properly substantiated, and condonation should never be approached as a procedural formality.
For advice on a condonation application, a late CCMA referral, or any labour dispute, consult an attorney at SchoemanLaw Inc in Cape Town or Paarl.



